Showing posts with label dating. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dating. Show all posts

Friday, April 15, 2011

In China, No Deed Means No Dates

The effects of gender imbalance or marriage markets gone awry?
Although there are few concrete ways to measure the scope of involuntary bachelorhood, more than 70 percent of single women in a recent survey said they would tie the knot only with a prospective husband who owned a home.

Among the qualities they seek in a mate, 50 percent said that financial considerations ranked above all else, with good morals and personality falling beneath the top three requirements. (Not surprisingly, 54 percent of single men ranked beauty first, according to the report, which surveyed 32,000 people and was jointly issued by the Chinese Research Association of Marriage and Family and the All-China Women’s Federation.)

The marriage competition is fierce, and statistically, women hold the cards. Given the nation’s gender imbalance, an outgrowth of a cultural preference for boys and China’s stringent family-planning policies, as many as 24 million men could be perpetual bachelors by 2020, according to the report.

Zhang Yanhong, a matchmaking consultant at Baihe, one of the country’s most popular dating sites, said many disheartened men had simply dropped out of the marriage market.

“This fixation on real estate has twisted the popular notion of love and marriage,” she said. “Women are putting economic factors above everything else when looking for a mate, and this is not a good thing for relationships or for society.”

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Little Known Statistics on Relationships

romance Interesting:

  • The average man’s ideal woman is 60lbs lighter than him.
  • A woman will get chatted up in bar 6 minutes faster if she is wearing make up.
  • Last year 21% of dates were organized via e-mail and 5% of relationships were ended by text.
  • 98% of Americans have experienced unrequited love.
  • Ladies don’t drink more than 1.5 glasses of wine more than your date – a turn off for most men.
  • For every $5000 extra a woman earns over her partner, their risk of divorce goes up by 5%.
  • Over 2% of all heart attacks have been directly attributed to having a broken heart.
  • Divorce has been proven to reduce a man’s life expectancy by 3.7 years.

Source is here via here.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

What Would Men Do If They Didn’t Have to Impress Women?

impress_women Probably a whole lot of nothing:

What if a guy's job had no effect on his value in the marriage market? How would that affect a young man's career choices? He'd be a heck of a lot less ambitious:

This paper examines the extent to which human capital and career decisions are affected by their potential returns in the marriage market. Although schooling and career decisions often are made before getting married, these decisions are likely to affect the future chances of receiving a marriage offer, the type of offer, and the probability of getting divorced. Therefore, I estimate a forward‐looking model of the marriage and career decisions of young men between the ages of 16 and 39. The results show that if there were no returns to career choices in the marriage market, men would tend to work less, study less, and choose blue‐collar jobs over white‐collar jobs. These findings suggest that the existing literature underestimates the true returns to human capital investments by ignoring their returns in the marriage market.

Source: "Marriage and Career: The Dynamic Decisions of Young Men" from "Journal of Human Capital"

Something to ponder: If you're a natural Casanova are you likely to be less ambitious? Or given the current demographics on college campuses, will we end up with a generation of male college grads who never really get out of first gear?

Other questions:

  • Are men less likely to be ambitious in other populations where there are gender-imbalances in their favor?  (DC?  NY?  Religious groups?)  What about the opposite?  (China?  Silicon Valley?)
  • Are men who cohabitate less ambitious than their marrying peers?  (He’s good enough to live with but not good enough to marry.)
  • Do liberal divorce laws that favor women disincentivize men from marrying, decreasing their productivity?
  • How much of the gender-gap in pay can be attributed to men trying to impress women with their income?

(HT Tyler Cowen)

Friday, September 25, 2009

Why Church Going Guys Don't Have It That Bad With Women

The Man Who Is Thursday:
For all the complaints I have made about the bad dating advice, grotesque naivete about female sexuality and indifference to the plight of single men you will find in the contemporary church, I have to admit that guys in my situation are in fact in a lot of way a lot better off than their secular counterparts. These are the reasons:

1. The effects of female hypergamy are much muted.
2. There are more girls in church than guys.
3. Church girls are more likely to be virgins (or at least have low numbers of partners).
4. Church girls have been prescreened for good character.
5. Conservative churches will still shame women for infidelity and divorce (usually).

In short, church going guys have better dating chances than secular guys, and when they do find someone they want to marry, they are more likely to have a successful marriage.
Read the whole thing.

As a churchgoing single guy myself, why do I feel simultaneously hopeful and without excuse?

(HT Robin Hanson via Tyler Cowen)

Monday, October 13, 2008

No Room For Spontaneity: Is DC Really A Great Place To Be Single?

I was talking about this with a friend a few days ago over tea in DC. There are no doubt many singles in the DC area, but everyone always seems so busy it is often more difficult to form deeper relationships with people compared to other places I have lived.

One explanation for this is that people working in DC tend to be young, bright, and ambitious, giving them a very high opportunity cost for their time. This keeps everyone frantically busy and working incredibly hard. If you want to plan a meal with someone, everyone has to take out their blackberries and schedule at least three weeks in advance --with a high probability that it's going to have to get rescheduled. It seems like everyone is so busy trying to change the world, there's no time left to try to enjoy it.

With my fellow students, it's a little different. (Moreso with the PhD students than with the law students.) The past few days at school reminded me of this. Friday, I ended up running into a friend right after class and hung out for an hour. I then went to grab a sandwich over at Quiznos and texted Ali on the way. Another law student was there and we ended up talking for a bit. After he left, I was finishing up my sandwich and Ali came over (he had already eaten). A few minutes later Carrie and Jason showed up too. We hung out for 45 minutes or so -- Ali playing with my tablet PC and the rest of us sitting around talking. After they left, I started in on some work on my laptop when a friend from Orlando called. We talked for almost an hour. I finally did get an hour's work done on my computer and then started walking back to the library.

On the way back, I ran into a big group of PhD students (including Jason, Carrie, and Ali) who invited me to go to happy hour with them at Mei's. Naturally, I had to join in. I got into some great conversation with one of our professors (including some encouraging feedback on a research idea I have) and with the other students. From there, I ran off to one one of those scheduled dinners I mentioned with some friends from DC that ended up lasting until 2 in the morning (something unplanned). It was a fun time and wonderful end to a great day.

Saturday, I had a repeat experience on a smaller scale -- I went into the library later in the day to make up for not going on Friday, and not 5 minutes after I arrived I got a call from Karuna asking if I wanted to join her and Josh for dinner. We met up an hour later and went out for Thai food around the corner from school and then to Barnes and Noble afterwards, having ridiculous conversations along the way. Lots of fun.

While I did not get as much work as I had planned this weekend, the social tradeoffs were well worth it. They were also a wonderful reminder of how much I miss this kind of spontaneous interaction with friends and how much less of it I seem to experience here in DC than other places I've lived.

I'm not the only one to notice this:
I’m guessing the person who came up with the conclusion of Washington DC being the best city for singles, either never lived in DC for more than 2 weeks, or wasn’t single when s/he lived in DC.

Work culture of DC: DC is full of hard-working young single professionals, who put in 50-60 hour work weeks to get ahead in his/her career. I’d like to think that as a group, young professionals in DC are probably the most ambitious people there are in the country. But the majority of those people sees DC as a "stepping stone" in their career, nobody I know was "raised in DC", most people moved to DC for work, and probably will move onto other parts of the country after DC "launches their careers". Knowing that, singles remain single for that specific reason.

Social aspect of DC: Due to how much young professionals care about their own career, they care about each other’s just as much. When meeting a new person, and playing the 20 questions game that everyone likes to play so much (sarcasm), I often hear the question "so what do you do" before hearing "what do you enjoy doing", that just sums it all up for the social culture of DC. I’m sure it happens in all major cities in the US, but none as blatant as DC.

There’s a reason why DC has an extremely high amount of single professionals (population percentage wise), because a lot of singles want to remain single, and the "DC Culture" isn’t to the advantage of the ones that don’t. Lots of bars mean young people can have a great time in the city on weekends or after work, but it also means people have less motivation to "find a boyfriend/girlfriend" because they always have something to do.
Paradoxically, it may be that "great places to be single" are actually not so great for finding a spouse. In economic terms, if having a lot of fun stuff to do effectively reduces the relative cost of singleness, it could lead to an increased consumption of singleness. It could also tend to attract people who are not marriage minded and are looking for a fun place that fits that lifestyle.

Having said this, that might not be the only thing going on. I did a few back-of-the-envelope calculations on singles in DC and here is what I came up with.


The lack of single men in DC may end up contributing to the high rate of dating and low rate of relationships observed by the blogger quoted above in a similar way that a lack of men affect "dating markets" on college campuses. The basic logic is that if there is an abundance of women relative to men, it helps create a "hook-up" or "dating without relationship" culture. The surplus of women creates a more intense competition for the men than you'd find a more gender-balanced environment, effectively lowering the price men have to pay to get affection and/or attention from the women. (This analysis is assuming that on the margin, less commitment is more male-centric and higher levels of commitment in dating is more female centric.) You also see a similar gender-imbalance among singles in churches which has a different, but significant effect.

With such a high ratio of rich/successful men relative to women in DC, there could also be a secondary "alpha-male" effect going on as well that leads many women to try to hold-out for high-status man, which could also contribute to a lower rate of relationship formation.

Bottom Line: Although DC may be a fun place to live while you're single, it may also be a tough place to find a mate.

Read my other posts on dating here.

Friday, October 10, 2008

More Women Than Men Pursuing Higher Education

Below is a chart of the gender imbalance in terms of associate degrees awarded that made based on data from a blog post by Richard Whitmire.



This chart shows that not only are there racial disparities in educational levels, but also that women of all races are more likely than men to finish at least associate degree education levels.

Whitmire quotes:
Bottom line: “Women outperformed men in college enrollment rates for all races/ethnicities. Overall, 44% of 18- to 24-year-old women were enrolled in college in 2006, compared with 36% of men.”
So what exactly does all this mean? I'm not entirely sure, but the shortage of men on college campuses is already starting to affect the dating environment. Historically, women have tended to prefer men with education levels equal to or above their own. These numbers indicate there will be far more college educated women than men in the future, which could have a whole host of social ramifications such things as increasing the opportunity cost for a woman to bear children, increasing wages of women relative to men (possibly eventually exceeding the average salaries of men), etc. This in turn may make the old world of a father being the main breadwinner for the family increasingly rare and make competition for college-educated men increasingly intense.

There are a lot of social norms and expectations that many people of both genders hold when it comes to marriage which are based on the historical reality of more men going to college than women. It will be interesting to see how these norms change in the face of these new demographic realities.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

How A Shortage of Men Affects Dating in College & Church

How a shortage of men leads to a hook-up culture in colleges. The quoted text is from this article by Richard Whitmire [Microsoft Word File]. Read his associated blog post here.
Last year, the writer Laura Sessions Stepp created a stir with her book Unhooked: How Young Women Pursue Sex, Delay Love and Lose at Both, which described what the author says is lost as young men and women move away from traditional romantic relationships and toward fleeting sexual encounters. Not only are women gambling with their health, argues Stepp, but they are making decisions they will regret in future years. The hookup culture could leave them bereft of the skills to build real relationships later in life. Whether Stepp is "retro," as some of her critics charged, may be less important than the fact that the hookup culture shows no signs of reversal.

One key element to the pickup culture, however, remains unreported: American colleges are undergoing a striking gender shift. In 2015 the average college graduating class will be 60-percent female, according to the U.S. Education Department. Some colleges have already reached or passed that threshold, which allows anecdotal insights into how those imbalances affect the pickup culture. What can be seen so far is not encouraging: Stark gender imbalances appear to act as an accelerant on the hookup culture.

Biologists and social scientists can't be surprised by that observation. In the animal kingdom, it is well known that whichever sex is in short supply has the upper hand.

College campuses are not immune to such laws of nature, something I glimpsed while doing research into why boys are lagging in literacy skills and college attendance. In 2006 I visited James Madison University, a public university with 17,000 students. At the time, women made up 61 percent of the campus population.

As a result of the rising gender imbalances, the university has become "female centric." But while women may run the clubs, dominate in classes, and generally define the character of the university, the law of supply and demand rules the social scene. That's why the women are both competitive in seeking men and submissive in lowering their standards.

Men at the university don't dispute what the women say. "Since there's such an overwhelming number of girls, they have such competition between each other to get a guy," a male junior admitted. "The guys here aren't stupid. They're plenty aware of that and know that girls have to get into a fight over them, instead of what's normal with guys courting girls."
Does this mean that college campuses with a shortage of women will be more prone to have a traditional courting culture? Or are there spill-over effects from nearby colleges? (At male-heavy Virginia Tech, guys would simply go over to Radford to get a better ratio.)

Read the whole thing and be sure to check out the author's blog, WhyBoysFail.com.

What About Churches?

To a certain extent, you should also expect to see a similar effect in religious groups where women nearly always outnumber the men. Certainly a counter effect is in play where most large religious groups have more traditional sexual mores than the average of the population. On the other hand, this may explain why many singles groups I've seen at churches have so little relationship activity taking place. If there's an environment with 50 women and 25 guys, it's unlikely the guys will feel overly motivated to fight over the women with quite the vigor the women might prefer. However, for men devoted to their religion, they less likely to lower their sexual mores in the same way college students do.

Assuming levels of religious devotion are positively correlated with strict sexual mores, it seems like this would lead to several effects:

1) Men who have less devotion to their religion will find lower-cost substitutes and date outside the religion and/or less devoted women.

2) Men who have more devotion may pay the high price to date devoted women, but in lower quantities than either gender would prefer, leading to low rates of traditional courtship.

3) Women with less devotion may lower their standards and date men outside the religion and/or men with less devotion.

4) Women with higher levels of devotion will maintain their high price in a market with an oversupply of similarly high-priced competitors.

It seems like this scenario would cause less devoted people to leave the group in the long-run, with the religious sexual mores having a similar effect to a price-floor for highly devoted people. This would lead to an excess supply of highly-devoted women charging "high prices" in the dating market, leading to lower levels of courtship than would exist at the "optimum".

This describes what I have seen in many Christian groups. Could it be that the maintenance of high levels of sexual mores actually leads to an underprovision of dating? (Note: I'm not arguing for a change, just observing effects.) In the long-run, this may actually serve as an incentive for religiously devoted people to stay married once they get married and help partially explain why people with high levels of church attendance have lower rates of divorce. Paradoxically, what's bad for dating could actually be good for marriage. This phenomenon may also explain why many women at Christian colleges scramble to try to get their "Mrs. degree" before they graduate.

(HT Todd Zywicki)

Friday, April 11, 2008

Why Are There So Few Eligible Bachelors?

How economics and game theory explain the shortage of available, appealing men. (I'm still trying to figure out what this says about me...)

...game theory predicts, and empirical studies of auctions bear out, that auctions will often be won by "weak" bidders, who know that they can be outbid and so bid more aggressively, while the "strong" bidders will hold out for a really great deal. You can find a technical discussion of this here. (Be warned: "Bidding Behavior in Asymmetric Auctions" is not for everyone, and I certainly won't claim to have a handle on all the math.) But you can also see how this works intuitively if you just consider that with a lot at stake in getting it right in one shot, it's the women who are confident that they are holding a strong hand who are likely to hold out and wait for the perfect prospect.

This is how you come to the Eligible-Bachelor Paradox, which is no longer so paradoxical. The pool of appealing men shrinks as many are married off and taken out of the game, leaving a disproportionate number of men who are notably imperfect (perhaps they are short, socially awkward, underemployed). And at the same time, you get a pool of women weighted toward the attractive, desirable "strong bidders."

Where have all the most appealing men gone? Married young, most of them—and sometimes to women whose most salient characteristic was not their beauty, or passion, or intellect, but their decisiveness.

Tyler Cowen doesn't quite buy it:
I view the real world auction as being held -- at least if you wish -- continuously rather than at discrete times. So the "strong bidding women" can always cave and settle for a "lesser man" after an optimal amount of waiting, yet many don't. The distinction between period-by-period happiness and overall lifetime happiness also shapes the market. As smart single women mature, their lives get better and better. "Settling" becomes psychologically harder, even if it would make some of the "settlers" happy in the longer run. So settling doesn't happen; decisiveness become harder to conjure up at the same time that its long-run value is increasing, or in other words behavioral economics is very much at work here.
(HT Richard Florida)

Monday, March 31, 2008

Singles Map of the United States


Hmm... maybe this is why I never found anyone while living in Florida? According to this map by Richard Florida, it looks like DC is a much better place for me to be.
Which of these two decisions do you think has a bigger impact on someone's life: finding the right job, or finding the right significant other? No one's going to argue with the notion that where you live affects your employment prospects. But the place you call home has a lot to do with your chances of finding the right partner as well. Having an enticing "mating market" matters as much or more than a vibrant labor market.

It's not just that some places have more singles than others. If you're a single man or a single woman the odds of meeting that special someone vary dramatically across the country.

By far, the best places for single men are the large cities and metro areas of the East Coast and Midwest. The extreme is greater New York, where single women outnumber single men by more than 210,000. In the Philadelphia area and greater Washington, D.C., single women outnumber single men by 50,000.

In fact, single women outnumber single men in many large cities around the world, even though men outearn women at all ages, according to Lena C. Edlund, a Columbia University economist. One reason young women in the prime marriage years - the 25-44 age range - flock to big cities is to compete for the most eligible men. And smart women who gravitate to vibrant cities are more likely to stay single - for longer, at least - because they rightly refuse to settle for someone who can't keep up with them intellectually or otherwise.

In our highly mobile society - where 40 million Americans move every year and 15 million of us make significant moves to a new county, a different state, or a different country - younger singles are the most mobile group of all. People in their 20s are twice as likely to move as 30-to-34 and 3.5 times more likely than 45-54.

I have often said, I recommend to anyone to spend their twenties figuring out what they want to do with their lives and who they want to spend it with. If you don't succeed at doing this in your twenties, start as soon as possible. (Assuming you want to get married, of course.) Armed with data like what is represented in this map, picking the right city just might help you with both goals.

Richard Florida may be right, choosing the right place to live is just as important as finding a spouse.

Monday, February 11, 2008

The Economics of Long Distance Relationships

Tyler Cowen:

From The National Post, the main sources are Tim Harford and yours truly. Excerpt:

The answer, says Mr. Cowen, lies in the Alchian-Allen Theorem. Developed in 1964 by economists Armen Alchian and William R. Allen, the theorem states that adding a per unit charge to the price of two substitute goods increases the relative consumption of the higher price good.

In layman's terms, "you don't take a long trip unless you are going to make it worth your while," he says. Very few people in a long-distance relationship are going to fly across the country just to hang out in sweatpants with their sweetheart.

The result is overblown expectations ("are we having fun now?") and excess pressure on the relationship.

Yup.

More on this here.

Tired of Looking For Love? Try Settiling!

"Marriage isn't a passion-fest; it's more like a partnership formed to run a very small, mundane, and often boring nonprofit business. And I mean this in a good way."

Romance advice from the Atlantic:

“Ah, this is the dream,” I said, and we nodded in silence for a minute, then burst out laughing. In some ways, I meant it: we’d both dreamed of motherhood, and here we were, picnicking in the park with our children. But it was also decidedly not the dream. The dream, like that of our mothers and their mothers from time immemorial, was to fall in love, get married, and live happily ever after. Of course, we’d be loath to admit it in this day and age, but ask any soul-baring 40-year-old single heterosexual woman what she most longs for in life, and she probably won’t tell you it’s a better career or a smaller waistline or a bigger apartment. Most likely, she’ll say that what she really wants is a husband (and, by extension, a child).

Whether you acknowledge it or not, there’s good reason to worry. By the time 35th-birthday-brunch celebrations roll around for still-single women, serious, irreversible life issues masquerading as “jokes” creep into public conversation: Well, I don’t feel old, but my eggs sure do! or Maybe this year I’ll marry Todd. I’m not getting any younger! The birthday girl smiles a bit too widely as she delivers these lines, and everyone laughs a little too hard for a little too long, not because we find these sentiments funny, but because we’re awkwardly acknowledging how unfunny they are. At their core, they pose one of the most complicated, painful, and pervasive dilemmas many single women are forced to grapple with nowadays: Is it better to be alone, or to settle?

Read the whole thing.

Eugene Volokh shares his thoughts:

I'm not sure the essay is right, I'm sure that it doesn't tell the whole story, and I am pretty sure that nothing in it is particularly original. But it strikes me as refreshingly candid as to one set of circumstances that are worth a good deal of thinking.

Tyler Cowen thinks settling is bad advice:

I am sympathetic to the idea of modest expectations but I don't favor cheerleading for settling.  If this article talks you into the prospect of settling, settling will start to seem pretty good to you.  If your expectations were too high in the first place you'll keep your old set of unrealistic expectations (personalities and pathologies don't change so quickly) and simply apply them to a new option, namely a marriage to a dullard.  "Settling" works best when you are stuck on a desert island and you do not expect so much from your surrender to the inevitable.  The AM article would do more good if it tried to convince people how terrible settling would be.  You just have to plant the idea in people's minds, as they'll make their own decisions anyway.

In other words, "have modest expectations -- it will be great for you!!!" can't really be winning advice.

Sunday, January 20, 2008

The Economics of Speed-Dating

The statistics:

Indeed, the data are here; we use them in a homework assignment in our book. The data were collected by Ray Fisman and Sheena Iyengar, an economist and a psychologist at the business school here, and they summarized their findings in this paper:

We study dating behavior using data from a Speed Dating experiment where we generate random matching of subjects and create random variation in the number of potential partners. Our design allows us to directly observe individual decisions rather than just final matches. Women put greater weight on the intelligence and the race of partner, while men respond more to physical attractiveness. Moreover, men do not value women’s intelligence or ambition when it exceeds their own. Also, we find that women exhibit a preference for men who grew up in affl­uent neighborhoods. Finally, male selectivity is invariant to group size, while female selectivity is strongly increasing in group size.

Maybe no surprises here, but that in and of itself is quite interesting...

And the economics, from and interview with Ray Fisman (HT MicroMotives):

3. Does your study measure how well what people say they look for matches with what they actually look for?

Most of what I do is work on corruption in poor countries. If I want to know how much someone is paying in bribes, I’m not going to ask them, “How much did you pay in bribes last year?” I’m going to say, “The guy down the street from you, who looks pretty much like you, how much did he pay?” Similarly, in the speed-dating study we ask people, “What do you care about?” We also ask them, “The average man, what do you think he cares about?” But then we actually see how they behave in the game. And, not at all surprisingly, what they say the average man cares about lines up much more closely with what they actually reveal through their actions than what they claimed they cared about beforehand. In particular, everyone — both men and women — says they care less about physical attractiveness than the average.

4. Do you think speed-dating is more efficient than traditional search methods?

In some sense, it’s efficient: there are all these slice studies on how 10 seconds’ worth of observation is as predictive of your experience with a professor as a semester’s worth, and they’ve reduced it to 2 seconds and that’s just as good; and they’ve reduced it to just a photo and that’s pretty good, too. So you learn a lot in four minutes, perhaps as much in four minutes as you do in a much longer superficial interaction like, say, a date. So, this does meaningfully provide you with 20 rapid-fire dates, to the extent that we form as much of an impression in 4 minutes, or 10 seconds, as we do in 4 hours. The thing that’s left out of this neat decomposition of people into attributes, though, is actually learning to love someone. And that’s what I think is kind of missing. Focusing on people as a bundle of attributes almost makes people think about this decision in the wrong frame of mind.

5. Do you think people become unwilling to commit because of all the choices dating services enable?

Yes. And the way that you can make these choices — just the very fact that it’s set up in this way — distorts the way people choose. There was an article in the New York Times on a backlash against Internet dating, and I wonder to what degree that’s at least partly as a result of these sorts of realizations.

6. The results of your speed-dating studies, particularly with regard to intelligence and physical appearance, seem to reinforce gender stereotypes. Why do you think this is?

Well, they are stereotypes for a reason. However, it’s not as simple as, “I avoid all women who are ambitious or intelligent.” It’s about, “Intelligence and ambition is OK until it supersedes my own.” It’s also worth mentioning that these are average effects — there are surely men who do not have this property. I like to think I’m one of them: my significant other is definitely a lot smarter than I am. When her grandmother heard about me, she said, “I told your mother this, and now I’m going to tell you: never let a man think you’re smarter than he is. Men don’t like that.” Everyone laughed and thought this was so anachronistic, but it shows up in our data. Grandma’s views on dating aren’t so dated after all!

Seems like this explains some interesting phenomenon in American dating. It confirms my impression that most Americans approach dating the way they approach shopping. I don't think that's a good thing.

I'd love to take some of these findings, build them into an agent-based model, and see how differing strategies among the agents compare against one another in finding a suitable mate.

Monday, December 10, 2007

Dating Pools

Ali just sent this to me. With my birthday coming up next month, I don't know if I find this cartoon more encouraging or depressing?



Sunday, September 16, 2007

Is Marriage the New Dating?

Dr. Helen Smith on the starter husband:
An article on MSN entitled "The Starter Husband" caught my eye this morning, mostly because the caption addressed to women seemed so ridiculously misandric: "You'd never buy a car without test-driving it first right? So why settle into a lifelong marriage before trying one on for size?"

The article, as one can gather from the title, is about women who marry in their 20's for practice and see nothing wrong with taking a guy out for a test-drive and dumping him off at the curb once the sheen wears off.
Here is an excerpt from the MSN article:
For some, a starter husband is like a starter home — a semi-commitment where you're willing to do some of the surface work, like painting the walls, but not the heavy lifting, like gutting the whole foundation; he's just not a long-term investment. Others compare a starter husband to a first job, where you learn some skills and polish your resume before going after the position you really want....

It's easy to write these women off as callous or self-absorbed. And yet on some level, they just might be pioneers: Why stay put in an empty shell of a marriage — an arrangement on paper only — instead of calling it what it is? "This generation is reinventing marriage," says Paul.
To which Helen Smith responds:
I thought pioneers were supposed to be brave people who ventured out to discover new things and make the world a better place, not cowards who are too afraid to say "no" to a marriage that they don't want just to "have a gorgeous party, and make my parents really, really happy" as one woman put it.
Read the whole thing and let's all hope this is not an increasing trend.

(HT Instapundit)

Friday, September 14, 2007

A Match Made on Earth

When Christians date outside the fold:
In an episode of "Seinfeld" that lays bare the characters' secular sensibilities, Elaine is shocked to learn that her on-again, off-again boyfriend, Puddy, is a believing Christian. "So is it a problem that I'm not really religious?" she asks him upon realizing their differing worldviews. "Not for me," he answers. "I'm not the one going to hell." Though Elaine herself acknowledges that she doesn't believe in an afterlife, she becomes increasingly angry with Puddy for not caring more about her eternal damnation. Finally, she explodes: "You should be trying to save me!"
Read the whole thing.

What sounds silly on Seinfeld is actually a very serious issue for many Christians. (See 2 Corinthians 6:14.) From the perspective of the economics of religion, the more value someone places on their faith, the more important it is for them to share that faith with their future spouse. This in turn means that being willing to date and marry outside one's faith in many religions is actually a signal that a person doesn't value their faith as much as they might claim.

One way to think about it is that a person indicates how much they value something based on what they're willing to give up to obtain it. (Hence Jesus' parable of the pearl of great value.) Christianity teaches that God should be the most important thing in the life of a believer. Anytime a Christian puts something else as a priority above their faith in God, it signals trouble for their faith.

Unfortunately, it is well documented that women tend to be much more religious than men on average. This creates a shortage of marriageable men:
For evangelicals who want to pair up with others of the same faith but don't manage to do so in their early 20s, trouble lies ahead, particularly for women. Evangelical churches now typically have a 60-40 split between women and men, which means that there are many more single evangelical women out there than their male counterparts. As Ms. Cockrel explains, "I have friends who wanted to marry a Christian guy, are still single, and are more and more open to dating non-Christians as they get older. They're tired of waiting."
This problem becomes more intense in places like Japan, where there the population is between 0.5% and 2% Christian and where the Christian women outnumber the men by a ratio of 3 or 4 to 1. It is similar to the shortage of black men for black women to marry.

I have several female Japanese friends who are committed Christians who face this very real dilemma. Their basic options are:
  1. Don't get married.
  2. Marry a foreigner.
  3. Marry outside the faith. (Something they are unwilling to do.)
They are in a very tough situation indeed.

To many non-Christians, the Christian prohibition against dating outside the faith often seems narrow and exclusive. From the standpoint of marrying someone who shares your beliefs and values and will help raise your children to have the same, this is a very wise strategy. (Divorce rates are significantly lower for people who share a common faith.) The more a person values their faith, the more committed they will be to finding someone to share it with.

Here are some of my previous posts on the economics of religion:

Monday, January 15, 2007

Biased Courtship?

Robin Hanson:
As we discussed recently, courting men seem too optimistic about their chances, while women seem too pessimistic about male intentions. Some explain these as due to high male benefit from mating success, and high female cost of poor mating.

Men willing to bother women even though those men didn't honestly think they had much of a chance would seem rude, selfish, and desperate. Women willing to reject almost all men while admitting those men had mostly good intentions and would provide enjoyable company would seem arrogant and selfish. Our biased beliefs help us retain our image as concerned about the interests of others, and not too desperate or arrogant, while actually being very eager (men) and picky (women).
Interesting...

Friday, December 15, 2006

Monday, December 04, 2006

Are Women With Graduate Dgrees More Attractive?

Following up on my previous post about education and dating, here's an excerpt from last week's Washington Post (emphasis mine):

As late as the 1980s, according to economist Elaina Rose, women with PhDs or the equivalent were less likely to marry than women with a high school degree. But the "marital penalty" for highly educated women has declined steadily since then, and by 2000 it had disappeared. Today, women with a college degree or higher are more likely to marry than women with less education and lower earnings potential. Highly educated women are also now as likely to have children as their less-educated counterparts -- and much more likely to have children born in wedlock.

(Hattip Greg Mankiw)

Tuesday, November 21, 2006

Education and Dating

From the New York Times:

Even as husbands and wives have moved closer together on measures of education and income, the divide between well-educated, well-paid couples and their less-privileged counterparts has widened, raising an awkward possibility: are we achieving more egalitarian marriages at the cost of a more egalitarian society?

Americans are increasingly pairing off by education level, according to the sociologists Christine Schwartz and Robert Mare. In an article published last year in the journal Demography, they reported that the odds of a high-school graduate marrying someone with a college degree declined by 43 percent between 1940 and the late 1970s. In our current decade, the researchers wrote, the percentage of couples who are “educationally homogamous” — that is, share the same level of schooling — reached its highest point in 40 years.

Assortative mating by income also seems to be on the rise. In a 2004 study of couples wed in the 1970s through the early 1990s, the researchers Megan Sweeney and Maria Cancian found an increasingly strong association between women’s wages before marriage and the occupational status and future earnings prospects of the men they married.

Hattip Greg Mankiw.